3manonMusic's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[One and Five over Eight]

{13/8 JUDGING REVIEW}
(please note we are rating score on a scale of 8-13)
Composition: 10
Mix: 9.5
13/8 implementation: 11.5

Additional thoughts: I like what you tried to bring in to the table with this piece. The noisy distorted guitar and the drums work quite well together. But the fact that there are only 2 elements in this piece is a bit off-putting, especially because the guitar gets quite jarring to listen to. This piece relies heavily on the noise from the distortion, but that is in my opinion not the best thing to put in the spotlight, as it is a really really heavy sound that kind of desensitizes my ears. I do like that you have a ton of variation in the piece, and get new motifs in from time to time. But because the guitar is so incredibly low in it's notes some melodies just get buried completely under the mud. It probably would have been better if you put it up an octave for at least parts, like when the new melody starts at 1:51 or at 2:36. I hope this helped, good luck at the contest!

[A+B : Damp Thicks]

{13/8 JUDGING REVIEW}
(please note we are rating score on a scale of 8-13)
Composition: 11
Mix: 10.5
13/8 implementation: 11

Additional thoughts: I like vibe you got going on here. It sounds very much like a jungle indeed. The tuned percussion helps a lot with that, so does the flute. I do have an issue with the sweeping synth, because it resonates a whole lot which can sound quite jarring to the ear (1:08 and 1:49 being the biggest examples). This got your score of mixing down a lot, so does the lack of bass. When I talk about the composition of this it's quite hard to find something cohesive in here. There's not really an intro, buildup, drop, or whatever. It stays quite consistent in that matter, meanwhile if I think about a jungle myself there's a lot of potential for dynamic storytelling in your song. In that regard it missed quite the mark, but I'm still scoring higher because it did match the vibe of the jungle, like aforesaid. The 13/8 is definitely present, but because the composition itself feels quite experimental already, the experimental time signature doesn't get the spotlight, that's why it didn't score as high. Good luck with the results!

[Solenne [NGADM]]

WOAH

[flowers]

Are these flowering fr fr???

[kłèikīos korīs (material artifice)]

Lyrics?

[Final Hours of Christmas (Jingle Bells - chipsqueek's NGCIJ24 Remix)]

NOOOOOO CHRISTMAS MORE LIKE SAD :(((((
THIS IS SUCH A GOOD SONG THO WTH

[May It Remain Untouched - [NGMT '24 WINNER PHASE 1]]

I have a feeling that whatever I'm listening to is the prelude of a world that is yet to be discovered. Every section I hear has a different mood, a continuation of the world and story you're building. A pretty harsh thing I hear overall tho is that the audio quality itself is not as good as the content of the audio. That shepard's tone in combination with that brass motif REALLY reminds me of "all quiet on the western front", which is an oscar-winning OST LMAO. Actually insane stuff in here, just like ADR3-N said tho it does have a bit of a lack of theme or motif. And yea just make sure to check your audio quality next time around :)

carboluka responds:

I'll probably have to go back and tweak this stuff eventually. I'll probably never do it but it's nice to think that one day I will and it will sound better lol

Thanks for the glowing review!!

[PUSHING THROUGH]

Rip pops 🙌

shletty responds:

thank you dude ❤️

[At The Lake]

Bro this part has been added to the megacollab, it fits super well and I totally love the vibe of the new stuff you added after the original part!

[STAYFOCUS]

Pretty good, except that at 0:12 the lead is extremely offsync which is a shame. Also it's really brick wall limited

TurboDrivee responds:

it was on purpose actually >:) i wanted to make it feel like the lead was loading into tune